The greatest advantage of having a strategy is being able to recognize when it isn’t working before it’s too late.
And those who use MAKE PROGRESS as their growth operating system also have the most efficient toolkit available to get their ship back on course—quickly.
In this note, I’ve identified 5 signals you can spot on the Strategy Focus Onepager (SFO), the most important tool for documenting, sharing, measuring, and, above all, frequently updating your strategy.
You’ll discover which canvas block to look at, which metrics to monitor, and some suggestions for how to respond.
Ultimately, every strategy is nothing more than a call for change, and change is a constant in every system. There’s no need to fear it—in fact, quite the opposite! We need to change our perspective and seek out change. To inspire you, I’ve also collected 5 stories to go with each signal.
These stories show how those who knew how to learn from these signals made such spectacular strategic pivots that they achieved success.
To better understand these concepts, I invite you to watch this video training, which uses a simple example to show how the SFO works.
As a side note, the KPIs are deliberately expressed in generic terms so you can adapt the concepts to your business.
Enjoy reading.
Signal No. 1: Declining product core metrics
SFO block to monitor: Product Core Metrics
Top 3 KPIs:
- Declining customer acquisition rate
- Declining user engagement
- Increasing churn rate
How to interpret the signal:
A significant decline in key product metrics is a warning sign of a possible disconnect between the current offering and the market’s evolving needs. This decline can result from various factors, such as the emergence of more innovative competitors, changes in customer preferences, technological obsolescence, or a decline in implementation, production, or delivery quality.
Suggestions for responding:
Conduct market research, analyze customer feedback, and monitor industry trends continuously—not just during a crisis. Consider innovating your product or service in a systematic, structured way. Also consider exploring new market segments or alternative business models.
The case: Nokia, from paper mill to mobile phones
Founded in 1865 by Fredrik Idestam as a paper mill in Finland, Nokia expanded into various industries during the 20th century, including rubber, electrical cables, and consumer electronics. In the 1980s, the company produced a wide range of electronic products, such as televisions, computers, and other household devices. However, during this period, Nokia began to record a significant decline in product-related metrics. Television and computer sales fell due to growing international competition and market saturation, highlighting a loss of competitiveness in the company’s traditional sectors.
Recognizing these worrying signs, the new CEO Jorma Ollila, appointed in 1992, decided that a strategic pivot was necessary to reverse the negative trend. Ollila carefully analyzed the performance of the various business segments and identified mobile telecommunications as the area with the greatest growth potential. Under his leadership, Nokia sold or closed unprofitable divisions and focused its resources on innovation in the mobile phone industry.
By investing heavily in mobile technology research and development, Nokia managed to launch a series of successful mobile phones that captured the global market. By the end of the 1990s, Nokia had become the world’s leading mobile phone manufacturer, turning a potential crisis into an opportunity for market leadership. This move not only improved the company’s product metrics but also established it as a pioneer in the mobile telecommunications industry.
Unfortunately, management failed to keep up with expectations when it later faced the same pressure with the launch of nine mobile phone models from competitors such as BlackBerry and Apple’s iPhone.
Signal No. 2: Radical changes in customer preferences
SFO block to monitor: Ideal Client / Market
Top 3 KPIs:
- Declining customer satisfaction
- Declining sales in key segments
- Increase in negative feedback or requests for new features
How to interpret the signal:
Customer behavior changes faster and faster than companies can adapt. Over time, solutions and products that once satisfied the market no longer align with current needs. This can show up as declining customer satisfaction, falling sales in key segments, and an increase in negative feedback. It is crucial to recognize these signals in time; if ignored, they could lead to a significant loss of market share and give competitors the chance to fill the gap.
Suggestions for responding:
Once again, customers prove to be the best consultants. Consider adapting or reinventing your products and services to align them with new preferences. Explore opportunities in adjacent or entirely new market segments.
The case: Nintendo (1889), from traditional playing cards to video games
Founded in 1889 by Fusajiro Yamauchi in Kyoto, Nintendo began as a manufacturer of traditional Japanese playing cards called Hanafuda. For almost a century, the company thrived in this niche. In the 1960s, Nintendo faced declining sales as consumer preferences shifted toward new forms of entertainment.
In 1949, the founder’s grandson, Hiroshi Yamauchi, took the helm of the company and realized that diversification was necessary for its survival. After unsuccessful attempts in industries such as taxis and hotels, Yamauchi recognized the emerging potential of consumer electronics. In the 1970s, Nintendo began developing electronic games, and in 1977 it launched its first home console, the Color TV-Game.
The real pivot came with the launch of the Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) in 1983. Faced with a market in which customer preferences were shifting toward digital entertainment, Nintendo invested heavily in developing innovative hardware and compelling games. Under the visionary leadership of Hiroshi Yamauchi, the company created iconic franchises such as Super Mario Bros. and The Legend of Zelda, redefining the video game industry.
This strategic pivot not only saved Nintendo from decline but transformed it into a global leader in the video game industry. The company continued to innovate with products such as the Game Boy, the Wii, and, more recently, the Nintendo Switch, continually introducing new ways to remain relevant in the lives of its customers.
Signal No. 3: Disruptive technological change
SFO block to monitor: Growth Machine Enablers
Top 3 KPIs:
- Reduced purchase frequency
- Increase in Lost Clients due to missing features
- Reduced ROI on strategic investments
How to interpret the signal:
The emergence of disruptive technologies can quickly make existing business models obsolete. If you notice new technologies transforming your industry and your products or services are no longer cutting-edge, it’s a clear sign that your company risks losing relevance. Inertia is the enemy of innovation. It’s essential to understand how new technologies can support growth and to avoid relying on technology as your sole value proposition.
Suggestions for responding:
Conduct an in-depth analysis of emerging technologies and assess how they could affect your industry. Invest in research and development to integrate these innovations into your products or services. Consider partnerships with or acquisitions of technology startups to accelerate the adoption of new capabilities. Review your business model to incorporate these technologies and create new sources of customer value. Analyze your processes and bottlenecks: how can you use technology to overcome them?
The case: IBM, from hardware to IT services and solutions
Founded in 1911 as the Computing-Tabulating-Recording Company (CTR), IBM began by producing scales, industrial clocks, and calculating machines. In the 1950s and 1960s, under the leadership of Thomas J. Watson Jr., IBM became a global leader in mainframes and computer hardware. However, in the 1980s, the advent of personal computers and growing competition in the hardware industry led to a significant decline in sales and profits.
In 1993, IBM appointed Louis V. Gerstner Jr. as CEO, marking the first time an outsider had taken on the role. Gerstner recognized that a hardware-centric business model was unsustainable in the new technological landscape. Seeing how technology was evolving and the shift toward more integrated solutions, he decided to pivot the company toward IT services and solutions.
Under his leadership, IBM shifted its focus away from hardware, selling some divisions, including its personal computer business to Lenovo in 2005. Instead, the company invested in consulting services, software, and tailored business solutions. Thanks to this transformation, IBM returned to profitability and strengthened its position as a leader in the technology industry. The pivot not only addressed the challenges posed by technological change but also created new opportunities for sustainable growth. This model is still relevant as I write this.
Signal No. 4: Significant regulatory or market changes
SFO block to monitor: Business as Usual
Top 3 KPIs:
- Increased operating costs due to new regulations
- Reduced demand due to market changes
- Increased fines or penalties for non-compliance
How to interpret the signal:
Sometimes it’s not just competition but also regulations or external market factors that put a company’s business model to the test. These changes can include new environmental laws, stricter tax regulations, or shifts in the industry’s competitive dynamics. Understanding that such changes can make existing processes obsolete and require rapid adaptation is business-critical.
Suggestions for responding:
Work with legal experts and industry consultants to fully understand the implications and identify hidden opportunities. Consider innovating your internal processes, adopting new technologies, or diversifying into less regulated sectors. Assess whether you can actively influence policies through dialogue with institutions.
The case: Piaggio, from ship furnishings and aircraft to scooters
Founded in 1884 by Rinaldo Piaggio in Genoa, Piaggio initially specialized in the production of ship furnishings and railway vehicles, and later aircraft. During the First and Second World Wars, the company became a major producer of military aircraft for Italy. Everything changed at the end of the Second World War: with Italy in ruins and the Allies imposing restrictions on aircraft production, Piaggio found itself in deep crisis.
In 1946, Enrico Piaggio, the founder’s son, began working with aeronautical engineer Corradino D’Ascanio to create an inexpensive scooter that was easy to ride and suited to the war-damaged roads: the Vespa was born. This vehicle perfectly met the need for affordable personal mobility.
The pivot was a direct response to regulatory changes that prevented aircraft production and to market demand for affordable transportation. The opportunity lay in converting manufacturing know-how and factories to serve a new market segment. The Vespa quickly became a cultural and commercial icon, exported around the world.
Signal No. 5: Erosion of sustainable superiority
SFO block to monitor: Uniqueness
Top 3 KPIs:
- Reduced competitive advantage over competitors
- Declining perceived quality or innovation of products/services
- Increase in competitors’ market share
How to interpret the signal:
Sustainable superiority erodes when a company can no longer maintain the competitive advantage that sets it apart in the market. This can happen when competitors improve their offerings or the company stops innovating, leading to a decline in perceived customer value. For a business leader, it’s crucial to recognize that sustainable superiority is not guaranteed forever; it requires a constant commitment to innovation, quality, and adapting to the market’s evolving needs.
Suggestions for responding:
Critically assess your product portfolio and compare it with your competitors’. Identify areas where your competitive advantage has diminished and invest in research and development to close those gaps. Consider adopting new technologies, optimizing processes, and innovating your business models. Engage with customers to better understand their needs and expectations, and use this information to guide product development strategies.
The case: 3M, from mining abrasives to continuous product innovation
Founded in 1902 as the Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company, 3M began by mining minerals to produce abrasives for industry. However, the poor quality of the minerals it extracted soon led the company to face serious financial and operational difficulties. The company had no competitive advantage.
Recognizing the need for change, 3M’s management, led by CEO William L. McKnight in the 1920s, decided to make a strategic pivot. They adopted the concept of sustainable superiority as a guiding principle, understanding that staying competitive meant offering products with measurable benefits that competitors would find difficult to replicate.
The first step was a major investment in research and development, which led to the creation of Wetordry waterproof sandpaper Wetordry in 1921. This innovative product outperformed competitors, solving practical problems for users and setting a new standard in the abrasives industry. Its sustainable superiority came not only from its quality but also from how difficult its technology was for competitors to replicate.
The drive for innovation continued with the invention of Scotch® tape in 1930 by engineer Richard Drew. This product opened up new markets and demonstrated 3M’s ability to create unique solutions that addressed specific customer needs. Its sustainable superiority was evident in the combination of proprietary technology and attention to market needs.
In the 1970s, the company continued to embody the concept of sustainable superiority with the creation of Post-it® Notes. Scientist Spencer Silver developed a low-tack adhesive. The project was initially considered a failure because an adhesive that wasn’t very sticky seemed more like a flaw than a feature. It was his colleague Arthur Fry who saw its potential for creating a revolutionary new product: keeping his place in sheet music without damaging it! Post-it® Notes quickly became indispensable in offices and homes around the world, thanks to their unique design and usefulness. Competitors’ difficulty in effectively imitating the product further strengthened 3M’s dominant position.
At every stage of its evolution, 3M has used the concept of sustainable superiority to guide its strategic pivots. The company has not merely responded to market changes but anticipated future needs, developing innovative products that offer tangible value that is difficult to replicate. Today, 3M is a multinational conglomerate with more than 60,000 products in sectors such as healthcare, industry, electronics, and consumer goods. Its commitment to sustainable superiority through continuous innovation has been fundamental to its success and its ability to adapt to market changes.